Explanation and definition: thesis and antithesis
https://doi.org/10.17021/2712-9519-2024-1-6-20
- Р Р‡.МессенРТвЂВВВВВжер
- РћРТвЂВВВВВнокласснРСвЂВВВВВРєРСвЂВВВВВ
- LiveJournal
- Telegram
- ВКонтакте
- РЎРєРѕРїРСвЂВВВВВровать ссылку
Full Text:
Abstract
The work is devoted to the assessment of the correspondence of the names of terminological dictionaries to the methods of semantization of the terms presented in them. The study uses a method that denies the synonymy of the terms "explanation" and "definition". The definitional analysis of these terms confirmed the alternative of their use in dictionaries of various purposes. It has been established that explanation as a method of semantization is correctly used in educational translation dictionaries intended for the initial period of study at a university, when the addressee begins to study special disciplines and does not possess the relevant competencies. Such dictionaries can be attributed to the type of "explanatory terminological dictionary". The definition reveals the meaning of the term in dictionaries intended for specialists who are well-versed in the terminology system of their branch of knowledge. Dictionaries of this type can be considered "industry terminological dictionaries". The use of the lexeme "explanatory" in their names is incorrect because it contradicts the method of semantization. Thus, the distinction between explanation and definition should contribute to relevance in the matter of choosing the source of information.
About the Authors
V. P. AndreevRussian Federation
Andreev Vladimir Pavlovich
candidate of biology, associate professor
St. Petersburg
Zh. V. Plakhotskaya
Russian Federation
Plakhotskaya Zhanna Vyacheslavovna
research assistant
St.Petersburg
References
1. Denisov P.N. Sistemnost` i svyazannost` v leksike i sistema slovarej [Systematicity and connectedness in vocabulary and the system of dictionaries]. Problematika opredelenij terminov v slovaryakh razny`kh tipov [Problems of definitions of terms in dictionaries of different types]. L.: Nauka, 1976. - Pp. 63-73.
2. Nesterov A.V. O definiczii "definiczii" [On the definition of "definition"]. Nauchnotekhnicheskaya informacziya. Seriya 1: Organizacziya i metodika informaczionnoj raboty`[Scientific and technical information. Series 1: Organization and methodology of information work]. - 2010. - № 6. - Pp. 1-6.
3. Griczanov A.A. Novejshij filosofskij slovar` [Newest philosophical dictionary]. - Moscow, Book House, 2003. - 1280 p.
4. Kiseleva A.V. Neobkhodimost` formirovaniya terminologicheskogo slovarya izuchaemoj disczipliny` v professional`nom obuchenii [The need to form a terminological dictionary of the discipline being studied in vocational education]. Materialy` 26-j Mezhdunarodnoj nauchnoprakticheskoj konferenczii "Innovaczii v professional`nom i professional`no-pedagogicheskom obrazovanii" [Materials of the 26th International Scientific and Practical Conference "Innovations in professional and vocational pedagogical education"]. - Ekaterinburg, 2021. - Pp. 41-43.
5. Akimova A.S., Fedorova E.P. Terminograficheskij razbor Slovarya lingvisticheskikh terminov yakutskogo yazy`ka M.A. Cherosova [Terminographic analysis of the Dictionary of linguistic terms of the Yakut language M.A. Cherosova]. Mir nauki. Socziologiya, filologiya,
6. kul`turologiya [World of Science. Sociology, philology, cultural studies]. - 2020. - Vol. 11. - No. 1. - Pp. 29-37.
7. Shelov S.D., Sun` Shufan. Termin kak osnovnaya edinicza terminologii: raznoobrazie opredelenij i edinstvo ponimaniya [Term as the basic unit of terminology: diversity of definitions and unity of understanding]. Voprosy` yazy`koznaniya [Questions of linguistics]. - 2017. - No. 6. - Pp. 102-114.
8. Ushakov D.N. Tolkovy`j slovar` russkogo yazy`ka: v 4-kh t. [Explanatory Dictionary of the Russian Language: In 4 volumes]. - Moscow, "Soviet encyclopedia", OGIZ, 1935-1940. Tom I: A-Kyuriny` [Vol. I: A-Kyurins]. - Moscow, State University, "Soviet encyclopedia", OGIZ, 1935. - 1562 p.
9. Evgen`eva A.P. Slovar` russkogo yazy`ka: v 4-kh t. [Dictionary of the Russian language: In 4 volumes]. RAN, Institut lingvistichtskich issledovanij [RAN, Institute of Linguistics. research]. Moscow, Rus. language; Polygraph resources, 1999.
10. Zherebilo T.V. Slovar` lingvisticheskikh terminov [Dictionary of linguistic terms]. - Nazran, Pilgrim, 2010. - 486 p.
11. Tikhonov A.N. E`ncziklopedicheskij slovar`-spravochnik lingvisticheskikh terminov i ponyatij. Russkij yazy`k: v 2-kh t. [Encyclopedic dictionary-directory of linguistic terms and concepts. Russian language: in 2 volumes]. - Moscow, Flinta, 2014. - Vol. 1. - 840 p.
12. Azimov E`.G., Shhukin A.N. Novy`j slovar` metodicheskikh terminov i ponyatij (teoriya i praktika obucheniya yazy`kam) [New dictionary of methodological terms and concepts (theory and practice of teaching languages)]. - Moscow, IKAR Publishing House, 2009. - 448 p.
13. Monogarova A.G., Latu M.N. Netochnosti i nedostatki v definicziyakh terminov razvivayushhikhsya terminologij (na primere terminologii mediaczii i informaczionny`kh tekhnologij) [Inaccuracies and shortcomings in the definitions of terms in developing terminologies (on the example of the terminology of mediation and information technologies)]. Vestnik Chelyabinskogo gosudarstvennogo pedagogicheskogo universiteta [Bulletin of the Chelyabinsk State Pedagogical University]. - 2016. - No. 8. - Pp. 171-180.
14. Ermakova L.R. K voprosu o razlichny`kh tipakh slovarej v obshhej teorii leksikografii [On the question of different types of dictionaries in the general theory of lexicography]. Materialy` III Mezhdunarodnoy nauchnoy konferensii. "Leksikografiya i kommunikacziya" [Materials of III International scientific conference "Lexicography and communication"]. - Belgorod, 2017. - Pp. 4350.
15. Popova L.V. Tipologiya i klassifikacziya slovarej [Tipologiya i klassifikacziya slovarej]. Vestnik Chelyabinskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta [Bulletin of Chelyabinsk State University]. - 2012. - No. 20(274). Philology. Art history. - Vol. 67. - Pp. 106-13.
16. Sorokoletov F.P. Obshhaya i uchebnaya leksikografiya [General and educational lexicography]. - L., LGU, 1985. - 57 p.
17. Kotelova N.Z. Semanticheskaya kharakteristika terminov v slovaryakh [Semantic characteristics of terms in dictionaries]. Problematika opredelenij terminov v slovaryakh razny`kh tipov [Problems of definitions of terms in dictionaries of different types]. - L., Nauka, 1976. - Pp. 30-44.
18. Potikha Z.A. Lingvisticheskie slovari i rabota s nimi v shkole: posobie dlya uchitelya [Linguistic dictionaries and working with them at school: a manual for teachers]. - Moscow, Education, 1987. - 128 p.
19. Apresyan Yu.D. Izbranny`e trudy`: monografiya [Selected works: monograph]. Moscow, Publishing house “Languages of Slavic Cultures”. - 1995. - Vol. 1. Lexical semantics. - 480 p.
20. Latu M.N. Nekotory`e osobennosti definiczij i tolkovaniya termina [Some features of definitions and interpretation of the term]. Izvestiya RAN. Seriya literatury` i yazy`ka [News of the Russian Academy of Sciences. Literature and Language Series]. - 2017. - Vol. 76. - No. 1. - Pp. 60-68.
21. Trifonov A.S. Rol` predmetnoj i lingvisticheskoj kompetenczii pol`zovatelej dvuyazy`chny`kh terminologicheskikh slovarej v neobkhodimosti razrabotki tolkovo-perevodnogo slovarya [The role of subject and linguistic competence of users of bilingual terminological dictionaries in the need to develop an explanatory and translation dictionary]. Sbornik nauchny`kh trudov po materialam Mezhdunarodnoj nauchno-prakticheskoj konferenczii "Nauka, obrazovanie, obshhestvo: tendenczii i perspektivy`". [Collection of scientific papers on the materials of the International Scientific and Practical "Conference Science, education, society: trends and prospects"]. Moscow, AR-Consal LLC, 2014. - Pp. 101-106.
22. Mikhajlova I.V. Kriterii i sposoby` sostavleniya uchebnogo slovarya speczial`noj leksiki dlya studentov-inostranczev [Criteria and methods for compiling an educational dictionary of special vocabulary for foreign students]. V sbornike: Gumanitarny`e. estestvenno-nauchny`e i tekhnicheskie aspekty` sovremennosti. Materialy` XXXIII Vserossijskoj nauchno-prakticheskoj konferenczii [In the collection: Humanities. natural scientific and technical aspects of modern times. Proceedings of the XXXIII All-Russian Scientific and Practical Conference]. - Rostov-on-Don, 2021. - Pp. 82-85.
23. Marganiya E.V. Angloyazy`chny`j mediczinskij terminologicheskij slovar` kak istochnik nauchnoj informaczii [English-language medical terminological dictionary as a source of scientific information]. Nauchny`e vedomosti Belgorodskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Seriya: Gumanitarny`e nauki [Scientific bulletins of Belgorod State University. Series: Humanities]. - 2011. - No. (101). - Pp. 149-160.
24. Lovczevich G.N. Definicziya termina v ramkakh tradiczionnogo i socziokognitivnogo podkhodov v terminovedenii [Definition of a term within the framework of traditional and sociocognitive approaches to terminology]. Teoreticheskaya i prikladnaya lingvistika [Theoretical and applied linguistics]. - 2016. - Vol. 2. - No. 1. - Pp. 50-62.
25. Shakeyeva N. Problemy terminologii v obshem yazykoznanii [Problems of terminology in gteneral linguistics]. Vestnik Bishkekskogo gumanitarnogo universiteta [Bulletin of Bishkek Humanitarian Univesity]. - 2014. - No 1(27). - Pp.105-107.
26. Trifonov A.S. Vliyanie motivirovannosti termina na slovarnuyu stat`yu tolkovoperevodnogo uchebnogo terminologicheskogo slovarya [The influence of the motivation of a term on the dictionary entry of an explanatory and translated educational terminological dictionary]. Gumanitarny`e issledovaniya v Vostochnoj Sibiri i na Dal`nem Vostoke [Humanitarian research in Eastern Siberia and the Far East]. - 2015. - No. 3. - Pp. 61-69.
Review
For citations:
Andreev V.P., Plakhotskaya Zh.V. Explanation and definition: thesis and antithesis. Title. 2024;4(1):6-20. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.17021/2712-9519-2024-1-6-20